Guide
Cedar vs. pressure-treated pine for a fence in Ohio
Published November 18, 2026
Most wood fences in Ohio are built from one of two woods: western red cedar or pressure-treated pine. Both make a sound fence. They differ in how they look, how they age and what they cost, and the right choice depends on which of those matters most to you.
The short answer
Choose cedar if you want a warm color, flatter boards and less upkeep, and you are happy to pay more per foot. Choose pressure-treated pine if you want a lower price and you will re-stain on schedule. Neither is a mistake. The mistake is building either one badly.
What each wood is
Western red cedar is a softwood that grows in the Pacific Northwest and is shipped here. It is light, straight-grained and rich in natural oils that resist rot and insects. Left unfinished, its red-brown color fades to silver-gray in sunlight.
Pressure-treated pine is ordinary pine with preservative forced deep into the wood under pressure. The treatment is what protects it from rot and insects, and treated lumber is sold in grades rated for different uses, including ground contact. It starts paler, often with a greenish cast, and takes stain well once it has dried.
How they look and age
Cedar looks finished from the first day: warm, even and tight-grained. If you seal it, it holds that color for longer. If you do not, it turns a soft silver-gray over the first seasons. Many people prefer that look, and it does not weaken the wood.
Pine looks plainer when new, but stain changes that. Its color depends on the stain you choose and how well it is kept up. A stained pine fence can look very good, as long as the stain is renewed before it wears through.
How they move
All wood moves as it dries and as the seasons change. Cedar is more stable. It tends to stay flat, and it splits and twists less. Pressure-treated pine is often sold wet, and as it dries it can twist, cup or check, leaving gaps in the first year. This is normal for the material, not a defect, and it is why a pine fence should be allowed to dry before it is stained.
Rot, insects and Ohio weather
Ohio is hard on a fence: wet springs, hot summers and winters that freeze the ground and thaw it again. Both woods stand up to it when they are built well.
Cedar resists rot because of its oils. Resists is not the same as is immune. Wood that stays wet will decay in time, however good the wood. Pressure-treated pine resists rot because of its preservative, and the posts, which sit in the ground, need lumber rated for that use.
This is also why the posts matter as much as the boards. A post set deep in concrete, below the frost line, keeps a fence plumb through the freeze and thaw. A shallow post lets it lean, whatever the wood.
Fasteners matter more than people think
The preservative in modern treated lumber, and the acids in cedar, can corrode ordinary steel fasteners. A fence held together with the wrong screws or nails will stain and fail at the connections long before the boards wear out. Whichever wood you choose, ask what the fasteners are. At Apex, they are named in your proposal.
Upkeep
Cedar needs less. You can seal it every few years to keep the color, or leave it to gray. Pine needs a stain renewed on a regular schedule to look its best and to slow the cracking that comes with sun and weather. Either way, a fence that is cared for outlasts one that is not.
Cost
Cedar costs more per foot than pine, installed. How much more depends on the height, the style and the length of the run, so the honest answer is a figure for your yard, not a rule of thumb. We price both for the same fence, in writing, and you can compare the two numbers side by side.
Which to choose
- Pick cedar for a visible fence, a warm look and the least upkeep.
- Pick pine for a long run, a tighter budget and a stain you are willing to keep up.
- Pick neither until you have seen the proposal. It should name the wood, the grade, the fasteners and the post depth.
Both are built the same way at Apex, with the same posts, the same fasteners and the same written terms. If you are still deciding, request an estimate and we will price your fence both ways.